top of page

That's not what I wrote

Navigating Disagreements with Editors and Beta Readers: A Writer's Dilemma

I'm the first to admit as I find my way back to my love of writing, how terrifying it can be to expose yourself in a way that leaves you completely vulnerable to feedback. I'm sensitive about my "ish" just like the next person. Writing a book is a deeply personal and creative process, and it's natural to encounter differences of opinion with editors and beta readers. While their feedback is invaluable for improving your work, there may come a time when you disagree on certain aspects of your book. This post is intended to provide guidance on how to handle such situations and make the best decisions for your work wihtout burning any bridges.

1. Understand the Role of Editors and Beta Readers:

Before diving into disagreements, it's crucial to understand the roles of editors and beta readers. Editors possess professional expertise and are trained to evaluate manuscripts, offering suggestions to enhance the overall quality. Beta readers, on the other hand, are individuals from your target audience who provide feedback from a reader's perspective. Their opinions can be highly valuable, but they may not have the same level of experience as editors.

2. Reflect on the Feedback:

When faced with differing opinions, take a step back and objectively analyze the feedback. Remember that editors and beta readers have a fresh perspective on your work, which can help identify potential flaws, inconsistencies, or areas for improvement. Carefully consider their suggestions and determine if they align with your original vision for the book.

3. Identify the Core of Your Disagreements:

Pinpoint the specific areas where you disagree with the editor or beta readers. Is it a matter of writing style, character development, pacing, plot structure, or thematic elements? Understanding the root of your disagreements will enable you to better articulate your concerns and evaluate the impact of potential changes.

4. Weigh the Merits of Feedback:

Evaluate the feedback on its merits. Assess whether the proposed changes enhance the overall narrative, deepen character arcs, improve readability, or align with your intended target audience. Be open-minded and willing to consider alternative perspectives, even if they challenge your initial assumptions.

5. Communicate and Discuss:

Engage in constructive dialogue with your editor and beta readers. Explain your reservations and concerns while being receptive to their insights. Discuss the reasoning behind their suggestions and share your artistic vision for the book. A thoughtful conversation can often bridge the gap between differing opinions and lead to a compromise that satisfies both parties.

6. Trust Your Instincts:

Ultimately, as the author, you have the final say in your book's content. Trust your instincts and have confidence in your creative vision. However, it's crucial to strike a balance between preserving your artistic integrity and considering valuable feedback. Be cautious not to dismiss suggestions out of hand without thoughtful consideration.

7. Seek Additional Opinions:

If you find yourself at an impasse and are uncertain about whether to make changes or maintain the original version, seek additional opinions. Reach out to other trusted writers, authors, or mentors who can offer their insights. Different perspectives can help shed light on the situation and provide clarity on the best course of action.

8. Compromise and Iteration:

Remember that compromising doesn't necessarily mean compromising your artistic vision entirely. Consider implementing changes that align with both your creative intent and the constructive feedback received. Find middle ground by addressing the core concerns raised while retaining elements that are integral to your storytelling.

Disagreements with editors and beta readers are a common part of the writing process, and handling them with tact and open-mindedness is essential. While you may not always agree on every suggestion, maintaining open lines of communication and approaching these discussions with professionalism and respect is key. Ultimately, striking the right balance between your artistic vision and incorporating valuable feedback will help ensure that your book reaches its fullest potential.

Happy writing!

41 views0 comments


bottom of page